Saturday, March 20, 2010

The Breastfeeding Saga

Ahh, breastfeeding. What an adventure. How my children were being fed was the center of my thinking for the first week of their life. Now that that has changed, I feel fully able to take a step back and reflect on my experiences.

I started breastfeeding within an hour of their birth. It took a while after the c-section to fix and clean me up, and get the babies weighed/cleaned up and get their HepB shots taken care of, among other things. I was so anxious to start, because I knew that the sooner the better was important for success.

We tried (oh we tried) for their first 48 hours. We had several factors working against us. Anna's small size and my large chest were one of the biggest challenges. She had a very difficult time getting her tiny mouth around more than just my nipple (read:ouch). Her small size also presented another challenge- any baby has to work hard at nursing, and she didn't have the stamina to keep at it for as long as she needed to (who knows if her heart murmur also made things more difficult for her?). There was also the added challenge of TWO babies that needed to figure things out. Just when one baby finally had success, there was no down time to bask in that success - I immediately had to switch to the other child and start the painful process of getting things going again. The babes needed to be fed at least every 2-3 hours. It took 45 minutes to almost an hour for each baby to successfully feed. That means I only had an hour or so of down time before needing to start all over again, if I was lucky- even throughout the night. Some times, I had a 15 minute break- enough time to go to the bathroom and drink some water before starting the process again.

After the second night, I was in rough shape from lack of sleep and my own recovery. I probably slept 4 hours of disjointed sleep total in those 2 days. I just wanted to hold my babies, damn it, and enjoy them- not struggle to do something that hurt and frustrated all of us 24/7. I was getting upset that my husband got to do all the cuddling, all the diaper changes and had time to do things like go to the bathroom and brush his teeth. Sam was finally starting to get the hang of things during the second night. That second night feeding Sam that one time was one of the only times when I felt happy to be breastfeeding. If Anna was as successful, I may have tried to continue longer.

On the second day, the babies vitals were taken, and it was determined that they had lost 8-9% of their birth weight. It is a concern when they get to 10% and we were dangerously close. Because they were so small, they had a much smaller amount of ounces that they could loose. A 9 or even 7 lb baby has a little more room to lose a few ounces. We had a discussion with the pediatrician about the need to supplement very soon. We discussed using a feeding tube and I hit rock bottom- it was just too much and I was falling apart. The struggles and lack of sleep had done me in and I wanted to be DONE.

We called in a nurse and told her the decision through tears. She called in the lactation consultant and we had a long chat. We decided to pump and then supplement with formula afterwards to make sure the babies were gaining enough weight. Sam could have continued breastfeeding because he was getting the hang of it and lost less weight, but we felt strongly that both children were going to be fed the same way. I felt like a huge weight lifted because I knew I wouldn't be trying so hard and still have babies that were too small. So on the second day, I threw in the towel on nursing and turned to pumping.

Pumping went relatively well at the hospital compared to breastfeeding. It didn't take nearly as long and we were able to start working on a feeding routine by feeding both at the same time instead of feeding around the clock. My poor nipples which had already started to bleed from two days of constantly nursing began to heal quickly. That third night in the hospital, I actually got 4 hours of continuous sleep, which felt glorious! I was able to hold my babies and just enjoy them. People were able to visit me because my boobs weren't hanging out literally all the time(although I did make my mother and MIL leave the room while I pumped). And most importantly, the babies' weight started to rebound.

Once we came home on Saturday, I continued pumping. As we started to regain our normal household activities- laundry, washing dishes, taking care of our dogs- as well as baby care, pumping started to be a huge time drain as well. If I pumped in the living room, we needed to shut the curtains. If I was pumping in another room like our bedroom, I felt isolated. When people were visiting, I was shut away in a room by myself pumping. We are still on a 2-3 hour schedule, with eating at least every three hours. A friend of mine said pumping for one baby is like feeding twins (because you do one and then the other) and pumping for twins is like having triplets. Granted, it took less time to pump and feed than exclusively breastfeeding (and then supplementing) but it still took a long time. I was feeling very drained and frustrated that although I was pumping, we still were giving half breast milk and half formula via bottle. I was tired. So one week after the babies were born, I stopped pumping and we switched to exclusively formula. I felt free. I felt like I had my energy back. I felt like I could actually enjoy my babies. I felt like my husband and I could finally each contribute 50% of the baby care.

I know that had breastfeeding been a success, in time I could tandem feed and it would have taken less time than solely formula feeding. But ultimately, breastfeeding was not for me.

I still have moments where I feel like I failed. Where I have enormous guilt for not providing what I should for my babies. The closeness of breastfeeding when it worked was awesome- and I felt those great hormones being released. But more often I felt frustrated, in pain, and unhappy. A happy mom = happy babies, so deep down I know I decided to do what was best for our children. I firmly believe that unless you have a very strong desire to breastfeed your twins(which I did not- if you remember I was on the fence while pregnant) and are willing to get past what seems like the impossible, exclusively breastfeeding twins will not work. I have often heard people say that breastfeeding their baby was the hardest thing they've ever done. Times that by two and I think it is easy to understand why my children are now formula-fed.

In the end, I am happy. And a happy mom = happy babies.

21 comments:

juliane2004 said...

"A happy mom = happy babies" - This is so right.

I'm happy you're happy with your decision. I made the same one shortly after my daughter was born. :)

Lucky Jones said...

You shouldn't ever feel guilty over your decision. You are doing what's best for your babies by making sure they are getting their needs met and staying happy. BFing shouldn't be a requirement - I know many moms who didn't bf and they have happy and healthy kids :) I'm so glad you posted this as I have been on the fence over it too. I'm gonna try though, so we will see how that goes...

And I will absolutely be kicking every single person out of the room when I bf or pump! Even mom and MIL. And Josh doesn't really want any part of seeing it anyway lol!

Kate said...

Absolutely was that the right decision. I've told my DH multiple times so far that I'm so thankful we just had one, solely based on the BF alone. It's brutal!
You're doing great.

Paula Keller said...

Thank you for sharing this! And for your honesty.

I'm so not married to the idea of exclusively breastfeeding. I'm wondering if I can do some combination from the beginning of breastfeeding, pumping, and supplementing as a compromise. I want the benefits of breastfeeding, but I do NOT want to always have my boobs hanging out!

Already I feel so much pressure from my husband and others to breastfeed. I feel so caught in the middle, which is just crazy.

Ahhh... we'll see.

Glad you're feeling happy and are able to enjoy your babies! :)

sweetpeanme said...

Wow...I feel tired just reading your post...knowing that's going to be me in a few days. I'm so glad you posted all that...now I can prepare friends and family for what may come. I'm going to let my friends know they either need to visit on my fourth day of the hospital...or just wait until I'm home and settled!! I have no idea how breastfeeding will go for me either because I'm not completely sold on the idea either! Formula and shared responsibility with hubby sound just fine to me!

I am so proud of you for trying all those different methods and realizing what works best for you and your babies and going with that.

ap said...

Thank you for this post! As I start the countdown to my c-section the one thing I have the most anxiety over is breastfeeding. Glad to hear your thoughts and experiences...thanks for sharing. :)

Kerri said...

Good for you. I had no idea how hard breastfeeding was- I thought it was something that just came naturally. Then Camden and I had a very challenging time over the first several days. It's hard work!I seriously doubt that I would BF if I had twins. You need to do what's right for you and your family and I am glad Jake will now be able to help you with the feeding part.

Deen Family said...

Great post for all new moms to read. Breastfeeding ONE baby is so very hard. I can't imagine what feeding twins would be like. Near impossible I'm sure. You made the best decision for your family. Don't feel guilty...moms feel enough guilt over their job as a mother. Breastfeeing guilt is NOT worth it. Formula is a wonderful alternatve and your babies will be so happy and healthy!

Word Nerd said...

Breastfeeding can be really hard, even with one. I have a low milk supply, so I've been pumping and supplementing with formula and it's really time consuming. I don't know how long I'll be able to keep it up. I also completely understand the feelings of guilt and failure, but you're doing the right thing for those babies by doing what you need to maintain your sanity. I know it's been really nice for both of us to let my hubby be involved with feedings, too.

Elaine said...

This is just one more example of a mom doing what is best for her children and THAT is what is important and makes a GREAT mommy!!

I don't think I've ever shared this on my blog but I attempted to breastfeed Little Bug. Considering we only had 7 weeks to get ready for her :) I had to make the same decision that it just wasn't going to be the best thing for us. I had zero supply once we got her home and to get my supply going (considering she was adopted) was going to take much preserverance and determinination that I just didn't have. I wanted to enjoy my baby girl that I had waited so long for and attempting breastfeeding was a complete stress. LB is 100% formula fed & I really do feel we have that same intimacy in feeding that mothers have with their breastfed baby. I hold the bottle close and turn her body towards me just as if she is being breastfed. LB is almost 10 months and because I love feeding her so much with the bottle and it is an intimate time for us, she does not hold her bottle still!!

Sure I felt some guilt because I hadn't even been able to carry her for the 9 months so I really wanted to be able to BF her. But in the end, formula was the best choice for us and now, almost 10 months later, there are still no regrets. :)

Heidi said...

I am glad you gave it a try. I completely agree that if you do not have a strong desire to BF (especially twins) it is too difficult. It sounds like you made the right decision for your family.

Lisa S said...

That's so good that you recognized what would be best for you, and in turn, your babies. I've heard breastfeeding is hard, and all from single baby mommies, I can't imagine that it's much easier with 2 or more. Thanks for sharing your story. I would love more details about the Madison twin sale. Not sure how you could give me the info, would you like my email? Thanks so much!!

Lisa S said...

Oh, wait, I just googled twin sale in Madison and found the details! Thanks for sharing!

Courtney said...

It sounds to me like you made a great decision. :-) My husband and I have already decided that we're not going to attempt breastfeeding exclusively. How on earth do people with twins do that???

jenn said...

i think you made a great decision....the one that is best for you and your babies! i have an 8 1/2 week old and am breastfeeding, but was never totally sold on the idea...i was just going to see how things went...it hasnt been easy...i dont know how long i am going to continue, and i do feel guilty for wanting to stop...thanks for this post

Anonymous said...

First of all congratulations on your twins! Second, congratulations on realizing that bf was not meant for you! With my second baby I had the hardest time, I had bf the 1st for 3 months, pumping most of the time because I worked. So I thought I would do the same with the 2nd. I was miserable!! Trying to feed a newborn(who had latching problems), pump so I could start storing milk for when I went back to work and entertain a toddler...it was just too much. It's all I would think about and it made me sad and I would cry all the time and so I finally decided after a week that it wasn't worth it and I never regretted my decision. And neither should you and if anyone ever makes you feel guilty, same on them! I always think it's good for moms to hear another side of the story and realize that there is nothing wrong with formula feeding and you did what was best for you and your babies! Congrats again!!
Emily:)

Anonymous said...

You didn't fail! Your sweet babies got the early immunity they needed from you. And now they get all the nutrition they need, and they get a more rested, happy mom! If you're happy, then you're bonding much better than you would be when you're exhausted and frustrated. You made the right choice for you and your babies! Feel good! :)

Spit Happens said...

I am SO proud of you Katie. You made the right decision for you and your babies. There seems to be so much guilt surrounding giving up breastfeeding or pumping and I hate that. Now you can just enjoy your twins and get more sleep! It's so important right now as you're recovering to get that rest and you just wouldn't have gotten it if you were still pumping (or trying breast feeding).

Lexi had so much trouble too with breastfeeding. Her little head next to my big boob was kind of a comical sight. In the end, you know it didn't work for us, but we did what was best for us and what works for us and that's what matters. When they are that tiny you really do have to figure in the weight loss thing. They don't have much extra fat to lose. Also, I cried when they put a feeding tube down Lexi, so I totally understand the breakdown. It was one of the lowest points where I felt like a failure that I couldn't provide what she needed. Bottle feeding is so much easier with low birth weight babies since you know exactly how much they are taking. You are doing a wonderful job!!!

Anonymous said...

I think you made the right choice. I too tried to nurse my daughter who was under 5 lbs and she did not gain weight very fast. I had to supplement her with formula and she slowly started gaining weight. She found the bottle easier and soon did not want to breastfeed. Enjoy your little ones

Lauren said...

My girl, I more than understand your decision! I've had a few cries due to being overwhelmed from feeling like I'm constantly nursing, and the pressure that comes from being the only person in the world that your baby actually depends on. I can't even begin to imagine what it would be like with twins. You must be so overwhelmed and exhausted!

By the way, the most sleep I've gotten in a night since Noah got here is 2-3 hours. And not all at once, either. AND I can't nap. So I empathize with the lack of sleep.

mishabear96 said...

My girls were born on March 9th too! Totally support your decision to move to formula. I've always felt defensive explaining to people that I'm formula feeding now. I managed to pump and feed one of the girls for three months, but only because my mother was with me during that time. Due to supply issues, the bigger twin got supplemented with formula pretty quickly after she came home.